This past weekend on my way home at past 3 a.m., I saw a car on the side of the interstate with it’s hazard lights on. As I got closer to my exit, I noticed that it was four young ladies trying to change a flat tire.
I got off on my exit thinking that someone else would stop, but I decided to get back on the interstate to check on them. That required me getting back on the interstate going in the opposite direction, just to get off at the next exit, get back on and come back in their direction.
This took me close to ten minutes and I thought for sure, by then either someone else would have stopped (the interstate was quite busy for 3 a.m.) or that they would have figured it out by then.
As I approached their car on the interstate, it was obvious that neither had happened.
I stopped and asked if they needed help, and they all said in unison “please”. So at 3 a.m. I got down and dirty and changed their tire. It only took about ten minutes and they were very grateful.
They commented that they had seen at least four police cars pass by and they couldn’t believe no one stopped to help them. They thanked me for rescuing them from being stranded and we went our separate ways.
This isn’t the first time I have been in this type of situation.
Once at a nightclub I heard a lot of commotion and saw a guy beating up a girl while dozens of people others by watching in horror. I fought my way through a crowd of people, thinking that by the time I got to that side of the club, someone else would have stepped in, but no one did.
I ended up being the one pulling the guy off the girl. I was shocked at how many others just stood by and watched.
A similar incident happened years later in a Walmart parking lot when someone was being attacked in their car by a guy. I heard the screaming, saw a crowd of people standing around and watching, and then noticed someone helpless was being assaulted.
I ran across the parking lot, thinking once again, by the time I got there someone else would have intervened, but no one did, and once again I ended up being the one pulling the attacker off of his victim while others stood around and watched (someone did call 911 but they didn’t get there for at least another ten minutes).
I am not recommending anybody should do either of the three things I mentioned above because it could have ended up badly, but it got me to thinking about why I felt the need to help in those situations and why do we in general, help others.
While most of us like to think that when we are helping others we are being purely altruistic, often times we are helping for egotistic reasons.
Egotistic helping is motivated by a desire of the person helping, to advance their interest, rather than the interest of the person being helped. The person being helped may benefit, but that wasn’t the sole purpose of the helping.
This occurs during times such as:
- we are just doing our jobs
- are interested in a challenge
- seeking power, fame, or recognition
- want to feel like a savior, rescuer, etc.
Some theorists believe that all helping is egotistic and that even when we are helping others, we are working for our own self-interest. This is called egoistic reduction, in which all helping is in the service of self-interest.
According to this theory, I intervened in the three examples above to be Superman, to rescue stranded, helpless individuals, and not purely for altruistic reasons.
Another psychological theory called negative state relive hypothesis says that we help to reduce the feelings of guilt we may feel if we didn’t help.
In the above scenarios, I agree that this may have been the case. Maybe I helped because if I didn’t, I would have felt guilty, if only briefly for not intervening when I could have.
Both of these are forms of egotistic helping, although other people benefited from my self-serving motives.
Other factors influence rather we are likely to help others or not such as:
- the weather
- our mood
- ambiant noise
- if we are in a hurry
- if we think other people are looking
- the attractiveness of the person
- the gender.of the person
We are also more likely to help those that we feel are similar to us. This is called similarity bias, a form of reflexive favoritism we usually don’t even know we are influenced by.
Lastly, according to evolutionary psychology, we help others because it’s in our DNA.
We help because we are all products of other humans who benefited from helping to ensure the continuation of our species. To understand this instinct we may call it altruism or morality, but it is ultimately instinctual.
If you look at helping this way, then all helping is egotistic as it serves to help pass on our genes as human beings to the next generation.
So why do we really help? Is it purely egotistic or biological? Chances are it is a combination of altruism, egotistic motives, situations and biological factors.
In the situation on the interstate, I know for a fact that I stopped because it was four attractive young ladies. I wanted to help because I knew it would feel good to be the savior, I was worried about their safety and would feel guilty if I kept going.
The next time you help someone, ask yourself why are you really helping? You may be surprised at the answer.
5 thoughts on “Is Helping Egotistic or Altruistic?”
Nice post….I really like it. In my whole lifetime I have never helped any stranger..or I can say I never encountered this kind of situation. During my job i always helped my patients not just because of nature of my job but purely out of humanity and empathetic attitude towards them. I have helped my friends on several occasions and if I think what was the motive for helping them was not due to any selfish motive but yes whenever I help my friends it gives me sense of happiness and satisfaction in a way this shows self interest. Whatever we do in life we do it because we want to do …nobody can force us to do something until or unless we are not willing. Again it is clear that we do everything to get happiness in our life.
I agree that we do everything to get happiness in our life, and also to avoid pain (guilt, punishment etc.) in accordance with the pleasure principle. A lot of times when I help without even thinking about myself, I later realize I did it either because it was my job, or it felt good to help, or I wanted to get that person out of that particular situation, I felt obligated to help or wanted to help them realize their potential for change. Those aren’t purely altruistic reasons, although the people I try to help usually do benefit. Some people think that people becoming counselors, social workers, etc., to try to help themselves and helping others is just a byproduct, and that people become doctors and such not necessarily to help save lives, but for the powers, prestige, wealth, etc., that comes along with being a doctor and helping people getting help is just an added bonus. I don’t believe the world is all that cynical or egotistic, but even if it is, at least people are getting the help they need in the end.
I like concluding lines…that people get help they need. Whatever may be the reasons but its our tendency to help others if possible or in our limits.
Great post! I’m actually not sure what to think, and it would make for a great thesis project, unfortunately or fortunately subjects would be hard-pressed to participate. lol Having said that, what if helping was as primal as our first biped ancestors … and basically chalked down to if I help, I die … or if I don’t help I die…
With any violent situation does one ponder their own risk of involvement? From your experience it would appear a likely factor, or did they feel it was none of their business? Like I said very interesting. I had read, I can remember where or when, but it was an uncontrolled experiment, but still interesting to see. A guy in his house decided one night to put on maximum volume for all his neighbours to hear a recording of someone playing drums. Needless to say, the police showed up rather quickly, the next night or something like that, he put in a recording of a woman being assaulted … no one showed …ever! Anyway, great post! Can’t wait to read more. Btw, Thank you for checking my blog.
Awesome and thoughtful comment. It reminds me of the murder of Kitty Genovese in NYC in the 1960s who was attacked in broad daylight and many of her neighbors heard her screams, but didn’t come to her rescue. After some time one neighbor called 911 and another screamed at the attacker, who ran away only to come back and finish killing her. Sad story. Many theorist say that this is the bystander effect where people are less likely to help a victim if there are other people there also witnessing (or hearing) the crime, and diffusion of responsibility, where people are less like to take action because they believe it is not their responsibility if there are others there who could take action and/or assume someone has already taken care of it (i.e. called 911). I think the bystander effect and diffusion of responsibility probably had something to do with the reason people stood by and watched as the people I talked about in this post needed help. People appear more likely to help when there are less people around.